before you read this, let me warn you there are spoilers.
i have been wanting to do this for a very long time now, but kept putting off. because of exams, i told myself. well now that i only have one paper left, and that doesn't really matter, i think (what am i thinking?!), i shall do a review of this manga.
of all the manga i have read, this is the best manga i have read so far. i admit, flame of recca, getbackers, fullmetal alchemist... etc, they have wonderful stories. but i think, sdk has the best story. i have never read a manga that is so emotionally charged and that which climaxed for so long. just when you thought the climax is over, another even more exciting fight or story came up. it continues on and on like that, without letting the reader get bored.
stories like flame of recca and getbackers especially, they have their little climax here and there. and of course, i really like their stories (especially getbackers 'get back the lost time' arc), just that, none of them are as continuous and emotionally charged as sdk.
sdk's climb to climax started very early, after kyo decided to find the aka no ou (the crimson king - aka means red, ou means king). from there the battles are all filled with a sense of purpose, not like some lame ass who came out and say, 'i want to fight you because i felt like it.' every battle has its own meaning. battles starting from saisei all the way till aka no ou himself, almost everyone has a purpose, and a strong will that says 'i will rather die than to lose, because i have something very important to protect.'
each battle gets more intense than the previous one, each one with a stronger reason not to lose. be it someone the person love, be it a dream, a tribe, the entire race... nearly everyone turned himself into the bad guy, to the extent of being hated by the very ones they wanted to protect, all in order to protect the things they treasured. yeah, you guessed it. nearly all significant characters in this story are good guys (women).
as for the reasons kamijyo akimine came up with for battles, they are really fantastic (well we don't talk about jokes like keikoku wanting to fight despite losing his left arm. i lol'd at that). why saisei fought so desperately against akira, why fubuki did the sacrificial technique to take down kyo, why kyoshirou was so determined to fight kyo, why yukimura wanted to defend sakuya so much, why aka no ou must win that battle, why ieyasu definitely must conquer the world...etc. you sometimes might think, with so many characters, with so many battles, is it even possible that a unique and yet acceptable and compelling reason to fight be created every single time? the answer is yes. kamijyo-san proved it. and he did it very well.
the story just keeps on attracting the reader and like an addiction, causes withdrawal symptom if the reader stops reading after a certain volume. yes, i think after the shinrei battle with kyo, the addiction kicks in. it may be earlier for you though.
story development: pretty well done. i will give a near perfect score for that. the only minor point is that i want to find about more about akira's past. he said before to yuya in the early parts when he proposed to her that he once loved a woman who suffered a tragic end. that part was never developed. ok back to the main point, other than a climax that never seems to peak, the flow is very well done. the suspense is always kept high and the best thing is, kamijyo-san actually fulfilled all expectations that he had created.
somewhere along the story, with all the hype and all the talk, you may begin to think, the relationship between kyo and kyoshirou better be something unexpected. the mibu secret better not be a lame secret. in fact i was fearing that. what if the mibu secret turned out to be something so lame i would just throw the last book away without reading? luckily not. it is one stunning secret that makes you think, 'well done!' expectations are all met.
character design: well dont look at the first few volumes. start from somewhere in the middle where better artists were employed. each character has a unique design, the most unique being akari! hahahax. you don't see repetitions in dressing and style of characters. honestly, you ask me to do that with a pencil, i cannot do that. the massive number of characters (yeah like bleach and naruto) and yet with no repetition makes one wonder how did the artist do it with just pencil or drawing tools. just their drawing technique could make one differentiate easily from one character to the next.
characters: well the characters are all varied too. from the all serious fubuki and hishigi, to the loyal and block head shinrei, from the sadistic oda nobunaga to the jokers bontenmaru and keikoku! lols i love keikoku. his presence is always filled with jokes. haha that reminds me of the bookworm in yuan's family, anthony. now i do know how do bookworms look like from kamijyo-san's perspective. simply amazing.
actually i saw the anime first before buying the manga. i did not really have high expectations though, after seeing the anime. well the anime sucked. but i don't know why i still went ahead and bought the manga set. something kept telling me to buy it, and so i spend another roughly 200 bucks to get that set. it must be the manga instincts within me. i totally did not regret it at all. and it tooked over my all time favorite manga (getbackers). heh, 'get back the lost time' arc is simply too good. the concept is fantastic too. well i will do a review on that one day.
anyway, the coolest person in the whole sdk story, i think is kyoshirou. and kyochiro is cool too. i won't spoil you by telling you who is kyochiro. hahax go read on your own. you know why i think kyoshirou is cool? go all the way back to the second post of this whole blog, yea the one right after the very first post, and see that picture. when i see it, i was like, oh my, kyoshirou is so damn cool! ok maybe when you see it like that it looks normal, but when that came out with the development of the story... the impact was really there.
ok i shall end this. this is a really good story, and although it is old, it is really very good. if you can, you should read it. i don't know if the english translation is good, but well i guess it won't differ too much, i hope. i was a little 'huh' when i read the translation of one of the chapters (when kyoshirou was telling yukimura his dream), the translation was very different from what i had. oh wells... better than nothing, right?